Dr. Melba Ketchum's Response to Bigfoot Is a Mix of "Possum and Other Species" Statement
A science blogger named Eric Berger released a bombshell the other day stating that a "a highly reputable geneticist" friend of his in Texas had looked into Dr. Melba Ketchum's data claiming that it was "a mix of opossum and other species." Apparently, Ketchum caught wind of the story, and she found some problems with the Berger's article. Ketchum posted this response on Facebook:
In response to the latest round of criticism. 1. We did give these folks access to the genomes. 2. They only pulled random sequences and did not look at the whole genomes. The person from UT that did our analysis told me that he never got all of the raw data uploaded to the second lab due to computer problems on the receiving lab's end. 2. I offered raw DNA to this lab so they could extract and sequence themselves. They would not even give the courtesy of a reply. 3. They refused to even speak with me on the phone. The entire thing was completely and totally unprofessional. 4. They never tried to check the analysis done at the University of Texas even though the bioinformatics person put himself at their disposal.
What findings they gave were impossible since both of our labs would have had to extract feces to obtain these results. If it had been feces, we would not have been able to obtain the preliminary results that we got prior to the genomes. After all, they were the same extractions. You can't get feces from tissue, blood and saliva. If we did extract feces, the quality scores would not have been this high. That is in the literature. This leads to a couple of possibilities. One, there is a conspiracy to suppress our findings. Two, they just didn't care and didn't believe that there is even the possibility that Sasquatch exists and therefore just wanted to be done with it because they had other projects. Three, they themselves suppressed it for fear that their careers would be damaged. The things that I know for sure are that it was not an adequate analysis, they did not even try to double check or recreate our findings. If they really had an interest, they would have jumped at the chance to resequence the raw samples. Funny thing, I offered the samples to three other places also and nobody was willing to test. Something is just not right. I also offered several people an opportunity to visit a habituation site including this reporter and his lab people so they could have a sighting. Of course they didn't want that either. Bottom line, nobody except a few of you here even care about the truth. Most would rather perpetuate that BF is a myth or an ape.
First Skeptic.
ReplyDeleteOuch!
DeleteMMG
I dedicate my first to Joe and MMG. Thank you all.
ReplyDeletepwned like only a footer can be.
Delete^^thank you, for the fantastic false first, congrats!!
Deletepwned like a sceptic trolling a bf blog.
DeleteFake fist
ReplyDeleteAs a geneticist who has seen this paper and their data, or at least what they offered, I can say it's the most pathetic thing I've ever seen and if I had submitted something like that as a first year genetics undergrad, I would have gotten a very low grade. No wonder they had to get someone to buy them their own journal to publish in and they don't send out raw data to anyone. It's truly laughable...and, sadly, I was really hoping for something truly interesting rather than a bunch of nonsense and playing the victim.
ReplyDeleteNice try dude. Melba you rock on girl, we know you have the goods and they're trying to suppress the findings ! You bet there's a conspiracy, this latest Snowden case shows just how much hidden stuff and lying they're is on government level.
Deleteif she had 'the goods', then why doesn't she publish raw data. that is required of pretty much every journal when you publish. you must make raw data available. i read her article and saw the "data" and it's absolute nonsense.
Deleteif you're such a big supporter, get her to publish the raw data so anyone can look at it. as it stands, when i do see data, it's not actually any raw sequence data...it's screen grabs of quality scores and crap like that. there's no conspiracy, just her lack of understanding of genetics.
You're not a geneticist you liar. Total Bullshit. Publish your name, Lab, and where you obtained your degree and Shawn can verify it to us . Melba hung her name and lab out there. If you don't then you're just that "magic monkey" Prick!
Delete4:52 still bleebs Melba, is functionally retarded.
DeleteNice to see a geneticist posting on a bigfoot blog. FYI - While you are wasting time here, there is a squatch posting on The American Journal of Human Genetics website
DeleteAnon 5:22 is Retarded because he can't spell.
DeleteSince we are correcting each other's spelling and grammar, I really like the unnecessary capitalization of retarded.
DeleteTrue dat Travis.True dat!!
DeleteWhy should a critic have to make their qualifications known if Melba won't even do that? She has no qualifications in genetics...she's apparently a vet with a 2 year degree from the 70s...and what qualifications she supposedly has she won't even make clear. I wouldn't speak as an expert about veterinary medicine just as she shouldn't do so about genetics.
DeleteAnd seriously...if someone wants to find me the raw data, I'm happy to look through it and comment on it and even have Shawn verify me. However, so far the 'data' I've been sent is not actually data that a geneticist would use in an analysis.
That's been my question all along. As far as I can tell she's a self-proclaimed geneticist.
DeleteIs there an accrediting body for genetics? As in, do you need to pass a board exam to call yourself a geneticist? Or can any Tom, Dick, or Harry just start up a lab and call themselves a geneticist?
Accredited? Degrees?
DeleteLeonardo Da Vinci not only was not accredited, did not have degrees, he had little or no formal education.
Go and look over some of his hand-drawn notebooks, his idea books, sketch books, then come back and shoot your mouths off about qualifications, degrees, accrediting.
Albert Einstein developed the Theory of Relativity while he was a patent clerk.
This worship of degrees and accreditation is narrow-minded, living in a box. Based on your thinking, you would have dismissed Da Vinci and Einstein.
Sceptards are such fumblers.
She was good enough to identify world trade center remains. She runs a genetics lab so enough with the Vet crap . In the 70's my job was basic as well and now I'm in a proffesional job.
DeleteTravis the capital "R" in retarded is for emphasis.
DeleteThe World Trade Center work is a blatant LIE. This has been confirmed by the NY Coroner's office and well-discussed MONTHS ago - where have you been?
DeleteShe does NOT run a lab!!! She closed it 18 months ago, and this fact was covered on this very blog, as well as others.
Delete"She was good enough to identify world trade center remains. ....."
DeleteAn absolute lie. Prove this.
Are you really comparing Melba Ketchum to da Vinci?? Sure, people can do amazing things despite a lack of a formal degree or a diploma, but those things serve as sort of a competency benchmark.
DeleteJust because Einstein did it doesn't mean everyone can.
Hey, she dared compare herself to Galileo, why not DaVinci? ROTFLMAO
Delete^^That's one hell of a good point!!
DeleteIf Anon 10:58 is using this site as gospel truth on Melbas lab closing and all the other silly crap then he is the most gullible Mutha F*cker ever.
DeleteWhat the hell is she talking about? Why would they have had to 'extract feces to obtain these results'? As I understood the Berger article, the other lab was given DNA samples, so extractions would have already been done.
ReplyDeleteHer "sciency" talk is a smokescreen meant only to make her followers think she knows what she's talking about and that she has been "wronged."
Deleteso what if it is a ape,an we all know she has never seen one up close or even one at all,she would have took pic;s to add to her DNA work, she needs more money,take people out to see one, what a joke this lady is, an I'm being nice///////
ReplyDeleteCheck out the Bigfoot photo on Robert Lindsays Beyond Highbrow website. It is the one with the copyright watermark on it. Scroll down to the very bottom of the page.
ReplyDeleteNo picture there.
DeleteJust a lame attempt to clicks on a pro-Dyer site.
The comments did however did contain a hilarious account (apart from a 70yr old having a heart attack) of Dyer's team tracker hike with Dallas & Wayne.
MMG
Means and methods for cover-up. Melba makes a breakthrough discovery...Paid officials try to ruin her reputation such as this site. Paid officials make every effort to not verify her results. Paid officials push the "bigfoot is a dumb undiscovered ape" quest or "bigfoot is a myth". Stand back and look at the bottom line. A discovery of another group of human hybrids with special abilities will be bad for business and society.
ReplyDeleteGood post sir.
DeletePeace.
Joe.
Wow, what an imagination!
DeleteBottom line? Who's raking in tons of cash because Bigfoots are running around the woods?
DeleteHuman hybrids with special abilities? Dude, this ain't the fucking the X-Men.
Close dude, alien probably. Who's making tons of money? I thought that was all bigfooters did, according to the skeptards. Meldrum, Moneymaker, etc.
DeleteI know that a stunk ape exist out in the woods.
ReplyDeleteCleetus smelled that ape. yessirree....
DeleteRussian leaping yeti. WOW I now believe in bigfoot 100%
ReplyDeleteLook at the way it changes from bipedal to quadrupedal motion in the last moments... the size of it's back and arss; you really wouldn't want to mess with the thing would you? My thinking is it's an adolescent, which sparks the imagination into thinking what a grown adult would look like??
DeletePeace.
Joe.
Peace Joe, I also believe in Bigfoot because I've seen Patty, the leaping Russian Bigfoot, and Harry and the Andersons.
DeleteThermalman and Mulder are giving each other the Double Dutch Rudder.
ReplyDeleteThermalman is thermally tuning Mulder's rear axle Mulder is getting ready to scream "game set match" as he gives Thermalman some thermal facial feedback.
Come again?
DeleteHe's talking about bff members. Why? I don't have a clue. At least he's not banging on about DWA.
DeleteI'm really not down with this BFF... Do I need to be?
DeletePeace.
Joe.
PLEASE sign up for bff joe! Would be hilarious!
DeleteGreetings joe: I left you a response on your question about Mr.Castaneda(Bigfoot Rooomate 6)..Always glad to read what you got to say..steve
DeleteHey Steve, just read your response and thanks for that. I'll go fourth and explore on the net but if I don't come across anything, I'll get some books ordered,, that is if they're still in print?
DeleteThanks again pal.
Peace.
Joe.
Found some... WOW! Right up my street, thanks very much Steve!
DeletePeace.
Joe.
I may read the link, I may not.
DeleteBut I can’t say that this surprises me.
When the whole approach is this sloppy, expect a result that’s not much neater.
OK, I read the link.
I actually have people on another forum actually arguing with me that the mainstream wha? SURE they take this topic seriously.
And we can’t even find out the “top of his field” genetecist’s name.
Oh. OK.
Now you see how this works?
As a skeptic that likes to laugh at footers all I have to say is hahahahahahahahaha
ReplyDeleteThis site is all about pumping the tires of Finding Bigfoot, BFRO and MM, demeaning any "real" science that's completed and allowing the APE band wagon to keep rolling. Shawn, you are sooo transparent it ludicrous.
DeleteSharon Shill is sounding rather Sharon Shrill today. Something must be getting under her skin.
DeleteSharon Hill looks like Jack Palance.
DeleteAs a bigfooter that likes to laugh at skeptards all I have to say is hahahahahahahahaha.
DeleteDo you JREF numbnuts bleeve Saskeptic is a PHD who's obsessed with a mythical creature like you bleeved Kitakaze actually made a living in the music business with nothing to show for it and like you bleeved Parnassus had 12 different professions and degrees ?.....and do you morons bleeve lying makes you a better pretend skeptic ?
ReplyDeleteyea but on the other hand you believe in a magic monkey man
DeletePOW! 9:06 am pwned again by a skeptic.
DeleteBigfoot's neither magic nor monkey, duh.
DeleteHer rebuttal makes no sense. Kinda like her paper.
ReplyDelete^ ?
DeleteLEEEMOORS,WES LEEEMOORS!POOSUMS EETS FOUR DINERS,THEYS EEGNORINT JOE,NUT NOOWS SWEETS DREEM POPPY FLOOWERS BRUNG LIKS US
ReplyDelete^
DeleteRiver ?
MELBUM SWEETS VAGINA BEEG IS GUD,YOOS SEEN SOONZ JOE VAGINA GUD,YOO LIKS GUD,CHUTACK,GOZ IN MIEND TAKS MOOR BEEG VAGINA,IS GUD,MELBUM GUDS TO US
ReplyDelete^
DeleteJREF footer "Resume" ?
CHUTACK,IS BEEG VAGINA GUD,NUT FOUR YOO,JUSS FOUR FOX AND FREEND JOE,YOO NUT SMAARTS LIK JOE,PROBOOBLY HAAS WIMMIN ALREDYS,NOT LIK FREEND JOE,WEE TAKS POPPY FLOOWER MEDISUM JOE,GOZ IN MELBUM MIEND ANS TAKS BEEG VAGINA,LIKS GUD JOE YOO SEEN IS GUD
Delete^
DeleteLongtime footer and pretend skeptic, Drew ?
WTF is that critter above and WTF did Fox just say? Never mind, I drank three shots and figured it out... HaHa...
ReplyDeleteMe see Cave Bear. Me run fast, trip brother. Brother make good meal for Cave Bear. Save me life. Paint picture on cave wall, of day when brother leave from bear. Woman no like picture. Woman paint picture of Sabre Tooth on cave wall. Me draw pee pee on Sabre Tooth, make correct. Woman no like. Me leave woman, go to cave where men sit and grow old. Me drink bad grape water and make bet. Loose wife on bet. Loose cave to Cave Bear. Me wait for bear to leave and me jump on Cave Bear. Ride, not like woman, but ride like need go somewhere. Me and bear become good friend. Bear liking bad grape water and gets bear self killed. Me find woman and start over in new cave. Me draw pee pee on all painting, make correct. Woman drink bad grape water and laugh and laugh.
Good to see the Jref 'Big Guns' on here. They sure need back up after the pounding they've taken over the last few weeks. Hilarious!
ReplyDeleteIf I could understand what the guy is saying, I'd happily take him apart... The guy's gotta talk in code cause I think he's a little scared to come out with it outright.
DeletePeace.
Joe.
YOOS GUD FREEND FOOREST PEOOPLES JOE,WEN MAKS GUD LOVS LADYFEETS YOO BEE TROOS MAN,NO MOOR LISSUN HOOSKER DOO DOO,YOO LISSUN RUSH GUD,BEE MANFOOT,THAYS NUT SMAARTS LIK YOO JOE,YOOS EEGNORINT,NUT BEE SMAARTS LIK FREEND JOE
DeleteKINS I HAEVS SUM GAERLICS JOE?
ReplyDelete^
DeleteRiver ?
Bigfoot= Butt People , Taterhole TRIBE.
ReplyDeleteWhoa, wait a second. Ketchup, sorry - I mean Ketchum - says, "Most would rather perpetuate that BF is a myth or an ape."
ReplyDeleteShe /does/ know that humans are apes, right? Like, is she one of these people that thinks "ape" is synonymous with "gorilla"?