The Bigfoot Community needs to wake up and stop being taken for a ride


Editor's Note: This is a guest post by Bigfoot Evidence contributor Freddy von Erich.

Lets be honest- for the better part of the last two years the Bigfoot Community has been victimized by Dr. Melba Ketchum. What this woman has done is trick everyone into playing a game of three card monte under the guise of a promise she will publish a paper that will change the world.

Take a step back. Melba Ketchum and her “camp” which includes a disturbingly loyal follower by the name of Sally, a female Bigfoot named Matilda and a horse, have been awful tight lipped when it comes to providing proof of claims she made, without anyone asking her to do so. Its clear there is an awful lot of manure in this camp and its not all coming from the horses.

Melba Ketchum was once a little known veterinarian from Texas. One day she woke up, had a cup of coffee and started telling a bunch of people she was going to prove Bigfoot is a real live animal. She attempted to create a vision of a Bigfoot dancing around with her in the role of Geppetto while singing I am a real boy.

She held herself out as a doctor and this got people’s attention. Then when people started to say “gee, just where is your proof”? we get a picture of what she called “Matilda”, a sleeping female Bigfoot. The Bigfoot world then gasped, the picture spread like wildfire and people knew that she really did have proof. Then the next question arose- “proof of what”? A sleeping Bigfoot or an old rug left on the side of the road? Melba did not like these questions and soon, Sally appeared.

Whenever someone dare question Dr. Melba Ketchum we saw something like this:

Sally here:

How dare any of you awful people ask when Melba will provide proof to a claim she made of her on her own, to a group of people, whose attention she sought? This is truly outrageous, Melba will do as she says and is a great person capable of doing anything, including time travel. Praise Melba. That is all.


People began scratching their heads saying “why is this woman, who made a claim, getting so angry when people ask her about it ?"

Soon Melba was in talks to be on television, regarded as an expert in the field of DNA, and even had her own public Facebook page. A star was born, but those pesky people, the ones who did not even know who she was until she made her claims, kept asking questions.

Polite questions like “when will this paper be published” were met with responses similar to this:

Sally here:

That’s it, nobody can comment on Facebook anymore. You were told not to question the word of the great Melba. This is our study and it will be done when it’s done and not a moment sooner. Praise Melba. That is all.


People then started asking even more questions. What samples are you using, where did you get them, can we see the video you claim you have of Matilda?

The response was something along these lines:

Sally here:

That’s it now the gloves are coming off. The paper will be finished when its finished. Its out for peer review and that can take up to 11 years. Everyone better stop asking questions, especially you, Robert Lindsay. Praise Melba. That is all.


Soon “fake leaks” were created about “Dogman dna” to throw Robert Lindsay off the scent. The camp made a decision- “lets not finish the paper, lets not answer any questions, lets not release our video- instead we need to put a great deal of time and effort into getting false information to Robert Lindsay”.

Now here we are, years after her original claim, we have no paper, no answers and no idea when and if it will be published. We don’t even know if there is a paper because we do not know the supposed journal to which is was submitted.

The Bigfoot Community needs to wake up and stop being taken for a ride.

Comments

  1. Freddy speaks the truth. Great Post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Its pretty simple guys... there is no bigfoot... therefore there is no DNA... therefore there is no paper worthy of publishing in a science journal. Its that fucking simple guys. Quit trying to make excuses.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Someone(Who just can't let WCCW go) rants about crap they know nothing about and got a bunch of facts wrong ie; Back track and look up Matilda!!! (It has nothing to do with Ketchum) And all you Anoms quaintly chime in.

      For the record, who looks more gullible now?

      Hell, why do any of you even care? She is making no promises to you or anyone. It's her own private project and anything we do KNOW about it came from her. The "Promises" are crap that came from Robert Lindsay and when it turns out wrong, you sheep take it out on Ketchum as if you thought RL actually had "Sources" and was not making this crap up as he went along.

      So all you trolls like wrestlers do you?
      Remember the one that said "Know your role and Shut your mouth!!"?

      Delete
  3. Is anyone else tired of seeing this Glamour Shot?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i would hit that box and she would like it :-)

      Delete
    2. ^I've seen her lately, you would not be making a statement like that if you actually see her in the flesh.

      Delete
    3. If you have low expectations your rareley disappointed.

      Delete
    4. Yes but Melba Ketchum is ' Miss Bigfoot ' and she has the dna to prove it.

      Delete
  4. Melba needs to be flushed until proof is released. Not even a "Soon to be released" should be posted. Wait til it happens. I wouldn't give them the time of day.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Melba has nothing. I wonder how many Unicorns she has treated during her illustrious Veterinarian career?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Melba has nothing. I wonder how many Unicorns she has treated during her illustrious Veterinarian career?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I wonder how many times you'll write the same nonsense.

      Delete
  7. 2 footers died and are waiting at the pearly gates. God says you have 1 question. One of the footers asks is bigfoot real? God says no. The footer turns to the other and says bigfoot is even more elusive and intelligent than we thought.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Two Skeptics are waiting at the pearly gates, and waiting, and waiting, and waiting.

      Finally God appears, "What do you want?"

      We want in! claims the Skeptics.

      No, there is no belief in you. I gave you the choice of free will, but you chose to bash others who belive in Me and other things for that matter.

      No, move along, you have no place here!

      Delete
    2. Of course the bigfoot haters liked this joke they're religious nuts.

      Delete
    3. That was a funny joke but how about this one...
      Two bigfoot deniers were walking through the forest when the ground begins to shake and a bigfoot walks up to them stands there. They are both frozen with fear. It breaks a large branch off a tree and snaps it in half. It pounds it on a tree. It howls at them and then runs off. One guy says to the other ' Wow, those costumes are getting better all the time '.

      Delete
    4. Yep, denial's always been a big part of many a Bigfoot skeptical pretender.

      Delete
  8. This sounds like another Michael merchant rant if i didnt know better. But whoever is writing this should get their facts straight. But as it appears, the writer is interested in providing false info to support their agenda here.
    The most obvious error is that Ketchum never released any photo. That bigfoot photo came from Erickson, not Ketchum. And it was released only in a canadian newspaper. The web then got ahold of it and ran with it. Ketchum had nothing to do with it, it was Ericksons photo.
    The next lie that is presented as fact, revolves around the bigfoot people are calling Matilda. Again, this was Erickson, it had nothing to do with Ketchum. This was a nickname the researchers gave the bigfoot that erickson was filming. Melba never made any claims about that animal what soever, nor does it involve her at all.

    Im as dissapointed as anyone else that nothing has come out yet. Does she have DNA evidence, of course, on some level at least. Will it come out, who knows. I dont care at this point anymore.

    But just b/c you are tired of waiting and have given up, doesnt give anyone the right to make up lies about this person to try and paint a picture of what you think. The writer tried to lie on 2 major posts in this article. So right their they have lost all credibility.

    Melba sucks ass in my opinion, but if your gonna bitch about her, why dont you get your facts straight so you dont look like a moron.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah,he should have talked about the blury stick structure instead. That was way more crazy.

      Delete
    2. It Michael Merchant had done a rant, it would have been more entertaining; and it would have included dancing.

      Delete
    3. I believe the "Sally here" comments were taken from this site and were made as a joke by yet another "anon" to express (or impress?) their personal views. Don't feel too bad about the mistake mystery "article" author as these impersonated "comments" reached a high sometime ago with the impersonation of Dr. Bindernagel... an article Shawn deleted in whole. The other errors pointed out also by anons above. When/if this eber gets published NDAs will fall to the wayside and we shall all have many good reads.....

      Delete
    4. Thats very true. The sad part, with all that Bindernagel crap, and their were many posts of it, was approved and posted by Shawn!!! He may have deleted it after he realized it was hurting his cause, but he initially approved all of it.

      Right now Shawn is at a good place in regards to the fact that somehow Justin has chosen to pal up with him. This will give him many hits. And hes in the position to earn some respect in the field. But hes never gonna be able to do that by publishing alot of the articles he is putting up. Between random nutjobs being allowed to guest post, tim fasano, rick dyer, michael merchant and several others, he is greatly hurting his credibility. He may be getting the hits from the website, and these nut jobs bring them in, but the really serious researchers out their really dont have a high opinion of this site at all. If shawn gets rid of all these loosers who post here, especially merchant and his friends, he will start to earn some respect with the masses. Instead of people laughing at how dumb the guest posters are.

      Delete
    5. FvE is another alias for someone behind this site dummies, they're all in bed together.

      Delete
    6. Oh yes those very serious researchers. The scientists around the world who constantly speak out on their beliefs.

      Delete
    7. OMG... you are going to bust on Shawn's "credibility"?

      Well you really serious researchers ought to do something about it! Like ask your Bigfoot friends to psychically command Shawn to feature you and hawk your books and DVDs! The Sas can just use their interdimensional portals to pop in and out of Shawn's place to do your bidding. And tell him not to leave his dirty dishes in the sink so long either!

      Shawn could care less about being a credible member of your community. He has a real job.

      Delete
    8. i dont think anyone out their is interested, or wants shawn to post them on this site, except the team tazer loosers, fatsano, dyer and fb/fb. The money being made here is off of pulling stories that have been around a long time. so yes your right, shawn has no credibility

      Delete
  9. Shawn has redeemed himself. Finally !!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Funny, my take is completely different. From where I stand, Melba Ketchum has made scant representations at all. No promises, no leading. All the fuss comes from the side that wishes there was more info. So I think the authors have their onus backwards.
    C

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I completely agree! She has made no claims. The author of this article sounds like an idiot. He does NOT have his facts straight at all. This blog truly is the National Enquirer of bigfoot news (or non-news). Why does it seem that so many people on this site dislike Dr. Ketchum?? Is it because she is a woman?? She is only doing what the bigfoot community has wanted for YEARS - a DNA investigation. It is ridiculous to jump up and down, pout like a child and engage in name calling because the published results are not on YOUR time frame. Why is everyone so hard on her? The information that people routinely post about her is always unsubstantiated and frequently makes the poster sound like a fool. What is discussed as "fact" by the commenters here is here-say and sounds utterly malicious. I do not know Dr.Ketchum and am merely following this from a distance, as you are, but jeeeezus boys! Give it a rest and have some patience! So what if it takes a few years? We've already been waiting decades! We have NO IDEA what is going on behind the scenes - NO IDEA. And don't pretend that you do because you don't.

      Delete
    2. Ketchum has made vague and open ended comments about her knowledge and evidence. She has never given an exact date but has led us all to believe that her report would be coming out "soon" or "eventually". Now, my definition of soon may be a month, your definintion of soon may be one year. Essentially, Ketchum has played the part of beign a great self-promotor of her product. Kinda reminds me of the old WWE football league that Jim McMhan toughted. He had all of us convinced that we were going to see guys in football gear body dropping and suplexing each other but in the end it was only a bad attempt at rehashing the same old game of football. Melba may be doing the same here. Getting everyone's panties all wadded up only to eventually discover that she has no new evidence. Only rehashing the same ol' same ol'.

      Delete
    3. The scientific definition of soon or eventually is unknown and different from outside life, that's what she's trying to say that she doesn't know exactly when it'll be. And anyway the haters here aren't serious skeptics those said their words long ago and left, these trolls are all in the unofficial knowledge the species is real. What we have here daily is back and forths from two parties both knowing full well bigfoots exist but the cynics have a job to do fighting it. So basically yes we all know it's real and just breezing until disclosure.

      Delete
  11. I keep my poop in a jar.




    I will now be selling my poop in a jar for only 49.95 plus shipping and handling.


    I will be calling this product "Dr.Ketchums DNA Review In A Jar"

    Please send payments via Pay Pal on E Bay to 'I keep my poop in a jar'.

    Thank you and God Bless.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yea majick poop! Will it come with some braded pony hair? If so sign me up.

      Delete
    2. Coincedintally, I keep my sperm in vials, stored in my freezer. I currently have over ten thousand samples. I daily tug at my tube in while gazing upon the amazon lady and her hot little friend. I place the samples in the freezer with the plan of eventually artificially inserting my seed into one of the young hotty female sasquatchs RL has spoken of. I will create a race of hybrids to be my slaves. I will rule the world soon. Good day.

      Delete
    3. Hey Shawn, this crap right HERE, tHIS IS WHAT YOU SHOULD BE DELETING, HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH bIGFOOT. sTUPID 12 YEAR OLDS.

      Delete
    4. We're talking about majick Bigfoot poop dumass.

      Delete
    5. Yea,It's the real deal magic poop in a jar!!


      So stifle yourself,please.I've already ordered 4 jars,1 for myself and the other 3 as Christmas gifts.

      Delete
  12. The tide is finally turning. Step up Melba !!!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Mabee you shouldnt stand here then, she has made claims .if you go back a couple of years when she was on blogtalk shows listen for yourself,about how she talks about its real and her report will be out by the end of the year

    ReplyDelete
  14. how do you prove something when it don't exist. everyone is milking the 'foots for all there worth. i predict in the next day another "Shocking proof" video will emerge. there will be the usual it will be out "soon" its worth the wait. wake up indeed. i didn't ride in on a turnip truck.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. no you are the guy that fell off of the turnip truck on its way in.

      Delete
  15. The only thing soon that is happening is Melba looking stupid

    ReplyDelete
  16. She seems to be a fraud... big surprise there.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No it's not actually, what is true though is that the trolls wouldn't be here if they didn't know or think it's real.

      Delete
    2. rum is true,you're full of shit

      Delete
  17. Can we please stop calling that black and white picture of a sleeping dog bigfoot.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Sally here. Soon you will all be eating crow. The paper is done, and will be published in a world respected journal. I'd give you the details, but your hate bores me; so I won't.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sally and Melba are the same person, split personality disorder.

      Delete
    2. Sally has always been Melba. I know this for a fact.

      Delete
    3. Have you ever seen them together?See,they are the same person.Duhhh.

      Delete
    4. ummm,I was with clark kent the other day and there was no superman news.

      Delete
    5. Sally is actually David Paulides.

      Delete
    6. And David Paulides is actually Kurt Russell.

      Delete
  19. The guy who wrote this definitely does not have his facts straight on several points. Nobody has even mentioned the "Sally here" quotes. Those are the "Sally here" jokester from here right? I don't think those quotes are from the actual Sally.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Of course those quotes are fake, and for that matter, posted with quotation marks, are subject to legal actions.
      You guys just don't get what's going on, right? If Ketchum does that only one thing she said she'll do, publish a scientific proof of bigfoot, this blog and dosens of other blogs and even organizations will just loose clicks and money and reason to exist. Except if Shawn switches to mothman or dogman or pigfoot or whatever.

      Delete
    2. "I'm Melba Ketchum and I blow ponies."Wow I put it in quotes,sue me bitch.

      Delete
  20. Good job, maybe you will be the one to provoke Ketchum to make a statement...good luck! You know your article is full of conjecture and half-truth, but we get your point.

    ReplyDelete
  21. She needs to step the hell up and act like an adult.

    ReplyDelete
  22. If you don't like the game, then take your toys and go home.

    ReplyDelete
  23. When all is revealed, all this stuff you guys are talking will be forgotten. Im as impatient as the next guy, but this has to be done right. Im gonna give Melba the benefit of the doubt.

    ReplyDelete
  24. don't get too impatient you might get what you wish for. that would dna proof of a non-existent creature. as noted above we still have mothman.

    ReplyDelete
  25. This could all be ended right here by Melba Ketchum posting on her facebook page what the title of the study is and what journal it is with and will be published in. There are services that keep up with submitted articles by title and could be checked for an independent verification that a study has even been submitted for peer review. Melba Ketchum herself, no one one else, is to blame for all the grief that she is getting. Especially when she is the one making statements like she has 5 bigfoots in her yard, and she just knows that they were the ones that were braiding the manes of the horses. Those are statements that came directly from Melba's mouth and noone elses. Just listen to the pass interviews that she has done and check her facebook page.

    ReplyDelete
  26. There is simply no reason why a DNA analysis should take so long unless you have nothing to analize. If this was a murder case you would have results in a week. I want to believe that there is a huge primate in North America, esp. since a new species was just discovered in Africa but I have no faith in Ketchum to prove anything.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. They're not wild apes like some believe goes without saying, primates like us yes but hominins. That is what's holding this back. I think they're not so much awaiting DNA results any longer or paper rewrites or anything like that, but the official okay to go ahead and release this new important information to the public. That is the work behind the scenes right now, the planning of how and where this presentation shall take place and in particularly when. It's crucial because it's bound to cause friction in especially religious circles, for one thing look how totally insane and irrational Muslims act right now over an innocent movie, but also the implications of new laws and historical reconstructions. All this has successfully been kept from people so far and now the bubble's about to burst, there must be serious discussions going on how to deal with it all. The only thing you won't do with news like this, unlike what many ignorants think, is rush out and show everybody the proof without any kind of preparations. It really isn't that easy mainly because you'd not be allowed to in the first place, there's opposition even from scientists planted especially to keep society calm.

      Delete
    2. I think you may be right. This type of news will be shocking and disturbing for many people.

      Delete
    3. Exactly. But nobody here truly cares about the truth, including the version that it does not exist. Once it's all out, the bigfoot community, now comprized of bf believers and bf skeptics (yes, both) will disintegrate, and the community of real researches will step up, blobsquatchers switching to Champ monster etc. Along Ketchum, Meldrum and a couple of others, Sykes will be in the first wagon, too - he was tipped it's real by one of the Ketchum's reviewers and jumped in to be there on time. All others are just pissed at the possibility she will end their game, or couldn't care less.

      Delete
    4. This comment has been removed by the author.

      Delete
    5. Thanks anon 10/59/and11:36, Scientists and researchers involved would have ignored and avoided this entire thing if there was no proof in the DNA study.
      Many may be upset that Sasquatch could be real maybe?

      Delete
    6. Anon 11:36 again - forgot to mention that the bf skeptics will move along the blobsquatchers to lake Champ. They can not survive without each other.

      Delete
    7. Yes, they'll be on to the next to troll mystery subject. Can't be the UFO subject for much longer either as that's abuot to be disclosed too within a foreseeable future.

      Delete
  27. Melba has already stated what her study was about. You guys must have missed it. Straight goods.

    Remember when the Bigfoot Lunch Club
    revealed Melba's Copyrights for books and Movies back
    in February? And they also published her Peer Review abstract available from the Library of Congress?
    Melba's premise was Bigfoot was human with certain mutations. DNA leading to that conclusion was also cited.

    ReplyDelete
  28. A murder case solved in a week???? Maybe on tv!Could you please give us a few references for that? I can give you plenty that took months and years and years to solve. And yes even with the new DNA technology. That is not even a realistic comparison.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Did not say a murder case solved in a week only that DNA could be analyzed in a week. I know ther is a backlog of DNA to look at but also that homicide's take priority over other cases. I don't even watch that kind of stuff on TV.

      Delete
  29. Sharon Lee says "That is ALL", not Sally. Just for the record. :)

    ReplyDelete
  30. indeed if there were some true then every big game hunter to joe sixpack will be out hunting these down like a gold rush frenzie.

    ReplyDelete
  31. why don't members of bigfoot community organize and "occupy" ketchum's place of business until she comes clean with some evidence or confesses to hoaxing..

    ReplyDelete

  32. Ketchums candle blew out ages ago, if or when she ever publishes something interesting then it might burn again but right now I have tired of hearing about her.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Hey what's the big deal. David Paulides can talk to them Bigfoots and have them stop by her office for a quick DNA test. So it's only been 2, 3...4 years now?

    ReplyDelete
  34. guy who wrote this article is an idiot.

    ReplyDelete
  35. I am not posting as Sally but whoever is, is using my catch phrase. That is All!

    ReplyDelete
  36. Ketchum is a DOUCHE BAG and her ass puppet Linsay the DOUCHE nugget are in it for the money and fame and thats all

    ReplyDelete
  37. You guys are pretty ignorant always ragging on why nothing has been revealed. You are too foolish too see that the exact same thing will happen with Sykes if and when he publishes. You cant talk about the content, period!!! If you do, you risk loosing the publication. She may never publish squat, but until its decided that their is no chance of publication, she must remain quiet!!

    Why dont you people get that? She has DNA evidence that will change things on some level, that is not disputed. Smeja, randles, meldrum and all the others have agreed on that fact. Will anything come of it, who knows? does she havve pics and videos and all that crap? who knows. Dont you think that if she wasnt going to be published that she would at least reveal what she has as far as dna results. It may only show that its non human primate, but thats something, and i assure you that she would rather post that than listen to a bunch of babies whine about them not seeing results. Apparently at this stage, their is at least some hope that it will still be published. Who cares if it doesnt.

    But one things for sure. The exact same thing will happen with Sykes. Do you see him releasing his preliminary studies? no. Because you cant or risk loosing the article. Damn people are stupid. And i dont even like Melba and that gay ass glamour shot

    ReplyDelete
  38. Anon on Sunday,9/16 @ 9:34 am is the only person whose comments are correct.
    Dr. Ketchum has a valid study, she also has the equivalent education of any Ph.D because of her post grad work, and she honestly carries the title of Dr.

    She earned that title, and deserves to be treated with respect.

    This project is a world changing event, everything must be perfect before the journal will publish,then,when the journal is happy, the DNA project is put into the line-up for publication.

    Depending on the journal that could be several weeks to months before it's published.

    I understand everyone being frustrated, but I suspect that Dr. Ketchum has suffered more than anyone else has through this event.

    I support Dr. Ketchum, and I believe that all of you will see the DNA proof soon.

    ReplyDelete
  39. Guys.

    If anybody had real proof of a sasquach that was scientifically viable or even a CLEAR PHOTO, it'd be all over the news.

    The reason Melba hasnt released the paper is because their is no paper.


    You are all being Hoaxed by Robert Lindsay. Mark my words. And you know what? Respect to Lindsey for doin a pretty damn good job so far.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Ketchum is legitimate and the real scientists in the research field and those involved in her study know it. Nobody else knows anything else- it's very simple. There are likely a lot of different things being coordinated right now to help support the evidence presented. And the evidence will change how we think and who we are so it is a very big deal. Anything that is scientifically strong and defendable will take longer than expected. Remember this post as it will reign true in the near future.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

BREAKING: Finding Bigfoot Production Company Seeks Filming Permit In Virginia

Samurai Chatter: Have you used it in the field?

Bigfoot injured by a forest fire was taken away and hidden by the authorities, not even Robert Lindsay can top this story